Wonderskin Eyeliner Pencil, 1440 Longwear Green Eyeliner Pencil - Waterproof, Sharpenable & Smudge Proof (Pine)

I am in love with this eyeliner! It stays on all day and goes on so smooth. The color is very pigmented and is accurate to what is shown online. I also love that I can sharpen the eyeliner to make sure that I have the cleanest, sharpest line possible. Honestly, I have tried so many different eyeliner pencil and this is one that I will continue to purchase as it is so good!

I am seriously impressed with the Wonderskin Eyeliner Pencil. The color glides on incredibly smoothly without tugging or pulling on the delicate skin around my eyes, which is a huge win for me. The pigment is rich and bold, so you get a clean, defined line in just one swipe. What really surprised me is how long it lasts. Once it sets, it stays put all day—no smudging, fading, or raccoon eyes, even after a full day of running around. It gives that perfect polished look without needing constant touch-ups. Overall, this eyeliner has quickly become a staple in my makeup routine. If you’re looking for a smooth, long-lasting eyeliner that delivers rich color and effortless application, this one is absolutely worth trying. Highly recommend!

Glides on good on my waterline which is sometimes hard to find in a pencil eyeliner. It’s not as water proof as I thought it would be. I have very watery eyes. And I’ll apply it and my eyes will water a little bit while I apply it and after my eyes stop watering I have to do another layer because some of it disappeared lol. I wish I just put it on and it automatically stuck. It works about the same as my urban decay eyeliner so I mean it’s not bad. It’s just not waterproof like it says. I do set mine with all nighter setting spray and it stays put. It for sure doesn’t stay put on its own. It doesn’t smudge but it does go away if your eyes water. (No idea where it goes lmao) over all it’s a good eyeliner. Black color is dark like I like. And it’s easy to apply. Smith application and good coverage on my waterline which line. Just takes 2 applications if my eyes water.

I’ve been using this eyeliner for a few weeks now, and I am honestly impressed! The Deep Black shade (Liquorice) is so rich and intense — it makes my eyes pop without needing multiple layers. 💫 ✔ Long‑lasting & waterproof — it stays put all day, even through work and errands. I haven’t had it smudge or fade easily. ✔ Smooth application — the pencil glides on effortlessly, which makes it perfect for tightlining or creating a bold cat eye. ✔ Smudge‑proof (most of the time!) — it holds up well, though I still set it with a bit of powder if I’m going to be outside for hours. I also love that it’s sharpenable, so I can keep the tip fresh for precise lines every time. ❤️ Overall: Great value for a high‑performance eyeliner! Whether you want a natural everyday look or dramatic evening glam, this liner delivers. Definitely one of my makeup staples now!

I’ve been using this eyeliner daily for about a week. I love the color and how easily it applies. I always apply it to clean eyelids and a dry upper waterline. I’ve tried adjusting the application by going thinner and thicker, and I even let it fully dry before opening my eyes — but unfortunately, it still fades completely after just a few hours. Because of all the hype around this product, I had high expectations. I don’t have watery eyes and I don’t rub or touch my eyes throughout the day, so I was really disappointed with how poorly it held up. I wanted to love this eyeliner, but the staying power just isn’t there for me.

I am seriously impressed with this eyeliner! I have really bad allergies, so my eyes water constantly throughout the day, and most eyeliners end up smudging, fading, or completely disappearing on me. Not this one. This stays put from morning to night—even with watery eyes—and still looks fresh. The formula glides on super smoothly without tugging, and I love that it’s easy to sharpen for a precise line. Once it sets, it does not budge, yet it’s still easy enough to remove at the end of the day with makeup remover. I’ve tried a lot of eyeliners over the years, and this one truly holds up better than most high-end brands I’ve used. If you struggle with watery eyes like I do, this is absolutely worth it. I’ll definitely be repurchasing!

So far I’m enjoying this eyeliner but if you’re looking for clean/ precise lines, this isn’t it. Pros: The formula is VERY creamy and goes on easily, it stays in place once it sets for about 20 seconds or so. Cons: when using this formula there is a learning curve that not everyone will have the patience for. Sharpening can be a pain and really messy. The tip breaks easily and the bits that come off will stain everything it touches including your skin and clothing. Because of that, getting a sharp point is difficult and expensive and it doesn’t last more than a few swipes. It also clumps up in your eyelashes when you try to fill in the space between your lid and waterline and you have to be quick about correcting your mistakes (I suggest getting the sharp Qtips meant for manicures). It does smear/ run if your eye gets watery. The video I took is self explanatory aside from the last line, I used an oil based face cleanser to remove that line. As for the pictures, the first is right after I applied it, the second was after I slept with in on (specifically for this review), and the last was after I used the oil based cleanser to remove it. All in all, yes there are more cons but I enjoy how dark it is and the way it makes my eyes look once I have it on. I’ve been using a liquid liner to clean up the edges and I think with time and experience it will get easier to apply.

I was honestly impressed with this eyeliner. The color is a deep black and it glides on very smoothly without pulling on my eyelid. Once it sets, it really stays in place and doesn’t smudge throughout the day. I also like that it’s waterproof but still easy to sharpen and use. It’s a great option if you want a long-lasting eyeliner that looks bold and clean.

Sin problemas

Amazing eyeliner! I have been on the search for an eyeliner for the waterline that applies creamy, deeply pigmented and actually lasts...and this is the closest I've found! It doesn't last all day, I may touch up once throughout a 14hr period, but this is way less than any other brand I've tried (including MAC and RareBeauty) which I would need to touch up 4-5x. I will be buying more. Love love love!

Me encantó el producto, la publicidad decía que duraba mucho puesto y no me decepcionó

Ist eigentlich ganz gut. Es färbt nicht so ab wie andere, verschmiert auch nicht so. Ich kann es schon weiterempfehlen.

I am impressed! This Wonderskin Pink eyeliner has really exceeded my expectations. I have long used various products (liner and powder/shadow) to brighten my eyes, placing it in the inner corners. I was keen to try Wonderskin's version and it is officially my "HG" for this purpose. I am fair-skinned, and their "pink" shade is light but bright, compliments my skin tone like no other. I have been putting it in the inner AND outer corners of my eyes, and it instantly makes me look rested. This isn't a shimmer product - in fact, it looks very very natural on my skin, I would say it's within the same tone of my skin (but obviously it's pink, and much more blue-undertones than my skin colour). Because it's within the same tone, it doesn't look like I'm wearing a product, and the brightness really sets off my eyes. This is called "longwear" and "waterproof" and wow does it stay in place without moving, fading or smudging. It comes off easily with micellar water at the end of the day. The texture of the pencil is soft/slightly creamy. It comes with a pencil sharpener (I would prefer a twist pencil, but for how awesome this product is, I'll gladly sharpen). For me, total HG and I would say perfect for anyone fair-skinned if you want a subtle but impactful brightening pencil. Great product.