- Peanut Butter & Co. Smooth Operator Peanut Butter, Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, 7g Protein, Non-GMO Project Verified, Gluten Free, Vegan, No Sugar Added, 16 Ounce (Pack of 2)

I only have this to say. This, is the best peanut butter I've ever had in my life. I can't stop eating it. Perfect taste, consistency and something unique about it I can't put my finger on. Maybe because it's organic and non GMO, AND Project Verified so I get to have REAL, actual peanut butter and not the fake, filler after taste I've come to despise in our food. I can not think how they can possibly top this rendition(Smooth Operator), but I'll be buying every single kind just out of curiosity. I don't know who could rate it less than 5 stars. They must not be true peanut butter lovers and should go back to Jif, which leaves more for me, so that works just fine.

Peanut butter as it was meant to taste. Not quite as “bare bones” as brands like Deaf Smith, and it does contain cane sugar and palm oil so it hasn’t separated, but it still tastes more of salted roasted peanuts than any of those big name brands that are filled with sweeteners and hydrogenated fats. Definitely worth buying if you want a more natural tasting peanut butter.

I was on the lookout for a healthier version of peanut butter and decided to try this brand. It did not disappoint! After a while, the oil rises to the top but can be easily mixed again and it tastes the same! Texture is the smooth and it's not overly sweet. Highly recommend!

Made a wonderful peanut butter toast! It’s really good I’ll buy again. Tried the smooth operator next time I’ll venture out with something different. I really like that it has limited ingredients.

I buy this for my mother, who used to buy Crazy Richard’s peanut butter but at age 87 it became too much for her to try to stir it. She called me and told me it was the most delicious peanut butter she ever had, and no stirring required. The subscribe and save price is only a bit over four dollars a jar, which I think is a very good bargain for natural peanut butter.

You really need to read the small print on this. It contains palm oil, one of the worst things you can eat. It does not have cholesterol, but it causes your body to produce cholesterol. Lots of saturated fats. Not good. If you love peanut butter and want to be healthy, get one made from pure peanuts like Crazy Richard's. Kirkland brand contains only peanuts and salt. Also, not visible until after you buy it: it is called "peanut butter spread".

This was a spontaneous purchase for a subscribe and save and I was pleasantly surprised. Not too oily, hearty, good taste. I don't have to mess with gobs of oil or feel like I'm eating fake peanut butter. This will be my go-to peanut butter from now on. My kids are grown, so I primarily use peanut butter for toast and peanut butter at night instead of peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, so I cannot attest to how well it spreads on untoasted bread, but was easy to spread on toast and yummy enough for me.

My favorite peanut butter in the world. Smooth, creamy, tastes like peanuts not oil. Made in USA & Non GMO. When you open the jar, no excessive oil sitting on top. Always smells fresh. Just a word of warning, try to order this when it will ship on it's own. I got it with a S&S order and the heavy items crushed one of my jars. Actually crushed a few things. Came home to a wet glob of peanut butter & body crème. The things my poor UPS guy has to go through.